Mutt Voting - Who is going back tonight?

Marvel is s.w.e.e.t.i.r.o.n.y.
Carr is c.e.l.t.i.c
Clove is s.p.i.n.a.l.
Octave is r.u.n.s.

Runs is a Sponsor. Somebody (S p o r k, id bet) recruited him over the other day.

Cordelia wrote:

Octave P O K E R?
Marvel S I
Carr C E L T I C
clove S P I N A L

I think this is the winner.

I thought p.o.k.e.r was Claire/mutt2. And I know A.n.a is Raile/mutt3.

I'm not 100% sure but I think Claire is Star my crotch

ETA: S.t.a.r.b.u.c.k

spo.rk is my crotch i think

s p o r k isn't playing.

No one has gotten Octave right yet, and I don't know if anyone will. He/She has been KILLING IT. So pulling for him (and Marvel) now.

Hi Seneca!

marvel! go get em.

Quinoa wrote:

I'm not 100% sure but I think Claire is Star my crotch

ETA: S.t.a.r.b.u.c.k

Also no. I confused everyone with a very layered post, but SB is also not playing (or a Sponsor).

Octave probably has my support at this point, but I'm equally pleased with the whole of the final four. All have played primo games.

octave = g.rah.am?

He's Mutt1.

Katniss wrote:

octave = g.rah.am?

No, but that's a good guess. He is/was Rue.

(jon, let me know if you want me to edit these out.)

Is Octave b.e.l.l.o?

If so, I do not remember him ever being this chatty. I have one more guess if it isn't him.

ack. it should be so easy. can we please get a list soon?

Arbor wrote:

Is Octave b.e.l.l.o?

If so, I do not remember him ever being this chatty. I have one more guess if it isn't him.

No, The D_Beeelllo was Foxface. : (

i thought we..ba but ack

Po' weeeeeeebaaa. He was Ole Day One Kill (Glimmer).

most times i am the chaperone for the midnight showing but this time i said no. now all the dang teens are pissed at me.

Please tell me Octave isn't z.y.k.e.

Arbor wrote:

Please tell me Octave isn't z.y.k.e.

hahaha, nope.

em.lyn?

No, but he was a Sponsor!

Hmmm. He said he had been to a redbank meet-up, that he's on Facebook and thought I blocked him because he kept talking about his cats and it's clear he likes football. I'm also assuming its a he. Maybe that's the problem?

He's a he!

possible champ?

Katniss wrote:

possible champ?

I don't know who that is, but his football team hasn't been a champ since 2008.

s.ir not?

Katniss wrote:

s.ir not?

No, but also good guess.

Not enough gifs to be V.i.r.g.i.l.

Is octave d.r.d?

No and no. Neither played : (

A couple folks had Octave pegged earlier in the game. But it's been a masterful performance.

Wait. Is it h.l.l.b.i.l.l.y e.d?

I know some folks were voting for a bad_jon. themed board if we keep this place open. But does anyone really want to frequent a place named in my honor? I'd feel a little self-conscious about that.

Is there a more accurate name for what this place might become?

Arbor wrote:

Wait. Is it h.l.l.b.i.l.l.y e.d?

I wish. I mean, I wish he'd played or come over at all. He's ignored all my advances sexual or otherwise. He won't even acknowledge my frozen crotch anymore.

Why not go back to Mafia Gathering Hole. Let's be honest. That's your audience.

sigh. ed. i wish he would come back.

i wanted to say gav, but not enough typos.

lo?

Arbor wrote:

Why not go back to Mafia Gathering Hole. Let's be honest. That's your audience.

It made me sad to see it closed up. I wouldn't mind re-opening the hole.

mafiahole.com is available.

Jon, I promised you my thoughts. Here we go.

What I loved - the anonimity. It was refreshing. It was also lotsa fun to guess based on players' posting style. I also loved that you couldn't tell who was lurking, something I hated about the old board. LOVED the assignment page. Whomever kept that updated for each player is a hero.

I loved the challenges, but sometimes there were too many questions to answer in the same day. It became a little tedious. It also forced me to be creative and role-play, and I appreciated that. FWIW, I put a lot of effort into my scavenger hunt photos, even though I know they were very literal. Can't help it, that's who I am. There should have been a category for most literal.

What I didn't love - I think you ended the village/alliance lynches way too soon. I know only one person was left from each alliance, but still. More lynches means more bloodshed.

I know this wasn't a typical mafia game but one of the things I love most about mafia is strategizing for the group good, be it mafia or village. With every one out for themselves, it was very hard to do that in this game. It was probably much different on the alliance boards. I think I would have said yes if recruited for that reason.

Not sure how I feel about the mutts. With such limited resources, how were we expected to kill them (twice it seems) and still have leftover to finish each other? I'm sure it was possible so I'll reserve judgment.

Overall, this was an incredible effort on all sides and I'm very impressed.